🔗 Share this article

On 10 September 1943, a casual gathering of influential acquaintances convened in a small apartment in the Charlottenberg area. Their hostess was Von Thadden, and the official excuse for the get-together was her younger sister’s 50th birthday. Truthfully, it served as a pretext for several key individuals convening to consider the future course now that it was clear that Hitler was losing World War II.

Resistance and Realization

Kiep, an ex-diplomat, expressed confidence about Italy’s change in leadership meant that Italy was ready to seek an armistice with the Allied forces. Meanwhile, the socialite Hanna eagerly looked forward to the end of the Führer: “He’ll face a firing squad.” Elisabeth, a devout Protestant and one-time educator of a prestigious academy, warned of the impending disaster that would follow the end of hostilities. To the attendees on that fateful day for tea and cake and a dismal confection called “ration cake,” Germany’s rebirth into a democratic nation state appeared imminent that they could envision it clearly.

From Patriotism to Resistance

None of these people were born dissidents. Many were from prominent army lineages who had been burned by the defeat of the Great War and the subsequent humiliation of the peace accord. To these quintessential patriots, the regime’s vow to restore Germany’s military pride, as well as prosperity, had been initially appealing. The restoration to the timeless principles of Goethe and Beethoven could surely not be far behind.

This naivety was short-lived. When the grim reality of the regime’s agenda for systematic persecution was revealed, it was impossible to stand by. In 1933, Kiep, serving as consul in the United States, endangered his position to pay tribute to the famous physicist, the most prominent exile opposed to Hitler. The act resulted in his swift dismissal back home. For Von Thadden, the turning point had come when she saw what the Third Reich aimed for Christianity – a state-controlled religion in which the Führer superseded Jesus Christ. As for Lagi, the duty was assisting those in hiding – fugitives – survive the terrible Berlin winters, then guiding them to freedom through underground passages and false papers. The countess had perfected subtle defiance: in all her movements, she made sure to hold luggage of heavy laundry on either side – this provided a plausible reason for failing to give the obligatory “Heil Hitler” salute.

The Informant’s Role

Unbeknownst to all until the trap was sprung was that a betrayer had infiltrated among them. He arrived during the gathering seemingly trustworthy, but with hindsight, there was something fishy about him. He listened intently to everyone’s words as if taking mental notes and sought to extract revelations about additional plans. The reason was he recorded each word and presenting it to the notorious Herbert Lange, the notoriously ruthless Herbert Lange. Soon after, nearly everyone who had been present that day would be killed or incarcerated.

The Unfolding Tragedy

In 74 short, punchy chapters, all closing with tension, the book follows the complex developments by which these unexpected resisters attempted to avoid and ultimately confront their fate. Initially an eerie quiet followed, soon occurred a knock at the door or a sudden arrest. Given that these were noteworthy captives with status or influence associated with the nation’s former aristocracy, it was certain that authorities would leverage them as political tools. There were show trials, featuring high-priced lawyers and witnesses and family pleas. Their efforts were in vain. Kiep was hanged, Elisabeth was decapitated. Zarden, a senior bureaucrat at the finance ministry, succeeded in escaping from his captors and take his own life, as for the others got long prison sentences.

A Page-Turner with a Powerful Message

Readers will find a rare achievement – an impeccably sourced history book that unfolds as grippingly as a bestseller. But it is equally a meaningful exploration, making readers ponder: Which among us would be brave enough to act defiantly, protest openly and confront the grim outcomes?